To achieve the 2 °C target, the total amount of carbon that can still be emitted by human activities is limited. This total allowable carbon emission—called the remaining carbon budget—is illustrated as an hourglass in the left panel. Previous studies, based on Earth System model projections with large uncertainties, estimated the remaining carbon budget at 352 billion tons of carbon (uncertainty range: 2–702 billion tons; black bar on the right panel). By accounting for the degree of agreement between model simulations and observations, the present study refines this estimate to 459 billion tons (uncertainty range: 251–666 billion tons; green bar on the right panel), substantially reducing uncertainty and improving projection accuracy. Credit: NIES

How much the planet warms with each ton of carbon dioxide remains one of the most important questions in climate science, but there is uncertainty in predicting it. This uncertainty hinders governments, businesses and communities from setting clear emission-reduction targets and preparing for the impacts of climate change.

The changes in atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations and surface temperatures are shaped by complex feedback between land, ocean, atmosphere and ecosystems, and this feedback can either amplify or mitigate warming. Reducing this uncertainty is critical to keeping the international goal of limiting warming to 2°C within reach.

New approach to climate projections

The team of researchers in Japan has developed an innovative approach to improve projection accuracy by combining climate model projections with observational data. The analysis was conducted using the results of numerical experiments on 20 state-of-the-art Earth system models that participated in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP5 and CMIP6), which contributed to the Fifth and Sixth Assessment Reports of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). The research is published in the journal One Earth.

The team examined not only how climate models respond to rising carbon dioxide concentrations but also how human carbon dioxide emissions affect atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations—a process governed by Earth’s carbon cycle. This involves how much of the emitted carbon dioxide remains in the atmosphere versus how much is absorbed by forests, soils and oceans.

Refining the carbon budget estimate

The analysis revealed that many models overestimate global warming relative to past carbon dioxide emissions. By bringing observations into the picture, the researchers narrowed the uncertainty in projected 21st-century warming and refined estimates of the remaining carbon budget—the total carbon dioxide that can still be emitted while keeping warming level below 2°C.

The horizontal axes represent past global trend in surface air temperature (1980–2014) in °C per 35 years. The vertical axis shows the remaining carbon budget from year 2020 for 2 °C by the CMIP5 and CMIP6 models for RCP8.5 and SSP5-8.5 scenarios, respectively (different colors correspond to different models). Pearson’s correlation coefficient (R) and relative reduction of variance (RRV, %) for two scenarios combined is denoted at the bottom of the panel. The black dashed line shows the ordinary least squares regression line and the gray shading indicates its 95% confidence interval. The horizontal box plot indicates the mean (white line), 17–83% range (box) and 5–95% range (horizontal bar) of the observed temperature trends of HadCRUT5 (pink). The vertical box plots show the same as the horizontal box plots but for the (black) and the constrained ranges using the observations (teal). The figure is adapted from Figure 3 of Melnikova et al. (2025). Credit: NIES

Previous studies that did not account for the degree of agreement with observations estimated the remaining carbon budget for limiting warming to 2°C at about 352 billion tons of carbon, with a wide uncertainty range of 2–702 billion tons. By taking into account the degree of agreement between the Earth system model and observations, the analysis refined this estimate to a mean of 459 billion tons with a narrower uncertainty range of 251–666 billion tons, thereby substantially improving projection accuracy.

In climate research, models that better reproduce the observed global temperature rise (horizontal pink bar) are considered more reliable for future predictions. By giving greater weight to such models, the analysis reduces the spread of estimates for the remaining carbon budget (vertical green bar) compared with the full model range (vertical black bar), thereby improving prediction confidence.

Understanding model differences and implications

This study sheds light on why estimates of future warming shift when emissions are used instead of concentrations. In the real world, not all of the carbon dioxide we emit stays in the air—much of it is absorbed by forests, soil and oceans.

How models represent this "airborne fraction" and the split between land and ocean sinks strongly influences their projections. In many simulations, models warmed the planet too quickly and underestimated how much carbon the land and oceans could take up.

By comparing these processes with observations, the researchers showed that some of the most extreme warming projections are less likely, which tightens the range of outcomes. Previous studies have not been able to improve the accuracy of Earth system models’ predictions of both land and ocean carbon dioxide uptake and temperature change.

The time series of emission-driven temperature change (°C) plotted against cumulative carbon emissions (GtC) for each model (different colors). The black lines indicate the mean and teal shadings indicate the 5–95% constrained range. The black dashed horizontal lines indicate 2 °C warming, relative to 1850–1899 levels. The figure is adapted from Figure 2 of Melnikova et al. (2025). Credit: NIES

Policy relevance and urgent action

These results strengthen the scientific foundation for climate policy by narrowing the range of future warming and the remaining carbon budget. More reliable projections give governments clearer guidance for setting emission-reduction targets, reinforce the credibility of net-zero pledges, and help communities prepare for climate impacts.

Beyond the immediate policy relevance, the new framework also offers a valuable tool for future climate assessments, including the upcoming IPCC AR7, where it can be extended to other components of the Earth system.

Yet the broader message is one of urgency: even with refined estimates and a somewhat larger remaining carbon budget, current emissions of about 11 billion tons of carbon per year would still deplete the budget for limiting warming to 2°C within just a few decades. Our results demonstrate the imperative to take urgent action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

More information: Irina Melnikova et al, Narrowed uncertainty in future global temperature and remaining carbon budget, One Earth (2025). DOI: 10.1016/j.oneear.2025.101526

Provided by National Institute for Environmental Studies

Citation: New approach narrows uncertainty in future warming and remaining carbon budget for 2°C (2025, December 6) retrieved 6 December 2025 from https://phys.org/news/2025-12-approach-narrows-uncertainty-future-carbon.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.