My decade old WD MyCloud still works perfectly. The drives are healthy. The network functions. But the mobile app stopped connecting years ago;Western Digital sunset the cloud services without warning. The hardware outlived the business relationship.

Meanwhile, my family defaulted to iCloud at $168/year. Forever.

That’s when I understood: In 2026, your hardware doesn’t fail. Your vendor relationships do.

The Real Cost of Cloud

When you upload to iCloud or Google Photos, you’re not storing photos; you’re feeding datasets. Your vacation trains facial recognition. Your kids’ birthdays become AI training data. Your entire visual timeline becomes product, not property.

And you pay $120-168/year for the privilege. In perpetuity.

iCloud Family (2TB): $1,678 over 10 years. Own nothing.

The terms change. Features paywall. Companies pivot. You keep paying or lose access.

This is the bargain: convenience now, dependency forever.

Why Build Instead of Buy?

Synology DS423 + drives: $790 AUD

• Beautiful interface, one-click apps, "it just works"
• But: proprietary OS, curated ecosystem, automatic updates you can’t control
• When they sunset support in 10 years, you’re stuck

My Build: $610 AUD

• N100 mini PC ($370) + 4× 1TB NVMe ($240)
• Ubuntu, ZFS, Immich, PostgreSQL; all open source
• When anything changes, I adapt. No vendor can abandon me.

The difference isn’t price. It’s sovereignty.

Synology optimizes for simplicity by removing control. I optimized for capability by accepting complexity.

The Hardware Choice: NVMe vs HDD

Why NVMe when HDDs are cheaper?

• 4TB NVMe: $240 upfront, $70 power over 10 years = $310 total
• 4TB HDD: $60 upfront, $520 power over 10 years = $580 total
• NVMe saves $270 long-term, runs silent, fits in your palm

Performance: 1167 MB/s sequential (5× faster than HDDs), 50k+ random IOPS (vs 150 for HDDs). Matters for thumbnails, galleries, facial recognition.

Trade-off: Can’t build massive arrays. But I need 3TB for photos, not 20TB for media servers.

NVMe isn’t splurging; it’s optimizing for silence, performance, and efficiency over raw capacity.

The Software: Choosing Freedom

• Ubuntu 24.04 LTS: 6 years of updates, then I choose when to upgrade
• ZFS RAIDZ1: Enterprise filesystem, bit rot protection, snapshots; no subscription
• Immich: Self-hosted Google Photos with facial recognition, ML search, automatic iPhone backup
• PostgreSQL + Valkey: Same stack powering billion-dollar companies

All free. All maintained by communities answering to users, not shareholders.

No vendor can sunset this. No company can paywall features. No terms can change.

The Economics

10-Year Total Cost:

• My NAS: $610 + $220 power = $830
• Synology + power: $1,310
• iCloud: $1,680

20-Year Total Cost:

• My NAS: $1,050 (just adding electricity)
• Synology: $2,620 (power + forced hardware replacement)
• iCloud: $3,358

After year 4, my cost drops to $22/year electricity. Cloud costs never decrease. Synology faces eventual forced upgrades when support ends.

But the real economics aren’t financial; they’re about control.

Cloud companies own your data relationship. Vendors own your software stack. I own everything.

What Sovereignty Means

• Photos on hardware I can touch
• No company can raise prices, change terms, or train AI on my family
• When something breaks, I fix it—no support tickets
• Software choices are mine forever
• Zero monthly fees, zero vendor lock-in

What it costs:

• $610 upfront
• One evening of setup
• Willingness to learn

Who Should Build?

Buy Synology/use iCloud if:

• Technology intimidates you
• Time is more valuable than money
• You trust vendors more than yourself

Build your own if:

• Control matters more than convenience
• You’re comfortable with Linux basics
• Vendor lock-in bothers you
• You value learning how things work

Neither is wrong. But only one is sovereign.

Why 2026 Is Different

Hardware: $370 quad-core mini PC was impossible five years ago. NVMe prices collapsed.

Software: Immich rivals Google Photos. ZFS is enterprise-grade. Ubuntu is rock-solid. The tools exist and are free.

Cloud costs: Rising steadily while adding AI scanning, government requests, and surveillance.

Vendor support: Companies sunset working products when support becomes unprofitable. My old MyCloud proved this.

You can now build sovereign infrastructure for less than pre-built solutions, with more capability and zero ongoing dependencies.

The Reality Check

This isn’t for everyone. If Linux scares you, buy Synology. If you can’t spare an evening, pay for iCloud.

But if you care about privacy, hate subscriptions, value understanding your tools, and worry about vendor abandonment;

What I Built

• 3TB usable storage (ZFS RAIDZ1, survives one drive failure)
• 1167 MB/s writes (10× faster than network can use)
• Silent operation (fanless, 15W total)
• Automatic iPhone backup with facial recognition and ML search
• Total control over every aspect

Works flawlessly. Family uses it daily. Photos sync automatically. Interface is fast.

And no vendor can ever turn it off.

The Conclusion

In 2026, we’ve normalized renting access to our own files. Photos don’t exist until uploaded to someone’s server. Privacy is suspicious. Surveillance is convenient. Working hardware gets abandoned when unprofitable.

Building a NAS is a small rebellion against this.

It cost $610 and an evening. It saves $168/year forever. It protects my family’s privacy. It can’t be sunset.

My NAS hums at 15 watts, hosting memories that belong to us. Not to Google. Not to Apple. Not to any corporation that might change terms or decide our hardware is too old.

Just us.

That’s not revolutionary. It’s just ownership.

And in 2026, ownership feels like victory.

---

Hardware: $610. Monthly fees: $0. Vendor lock-in: none.

Still renting your data, or ready to own it?