Siblings usually grow up together in the same house, with the same parents, and sharing the same cultural background, yet they still become remarkably different people with distinct interests and divergent life paths. This is a widespread occurrence in families, but in immigrant families, the phenomenon becomes even more pronounced, as cultural expectations, adaptation pressures, and family roles provide additional layers of complexity. Children raised in such environments must navigate between the customs of their ancestors and the practices of the dominant culture, but they do not walk this path in the same way.

Factors such as birth order, family dynamics, and personal characteristics help determine the extent to which siblings interpret and respond to culture. Understanding the differences among siblings and their sources is crucial for parents, teachers, and counselors who desire to support each child individually while maintaining healthy family relationships.

Birth Order and Its Influence

Birth order is a primary driver of role, responsibility, and family hierarchy, particularly in immigrant families. Firstborns generally take on much of the responsibility for maintaining high educational standards and upholding cultural values. They are often mentors to their younger siblings, and may assume adult responsibilities such as helping their parents communicate with the outside world or navigate institutions like schools and health care systems.

Such responsibilities can be a double-edged sword: They can promote maturity and leadership skills, but they can also lead to pressure and stress. Older siblings may feel that their accomplishments are not only their personal victories but also the family’s collective pride and honor.

Middle and younger siblings typically experience more flexibility. Parents often become more relaxed regarding rules and expectations based on their prior experiences with older children. Younger siblings may find more freedom to explore their cultural identity and develop independence.

Birth order never operates in isolation; rather, cultural expectations amplify its effects. In an immigrant family, for example, older children may take up caregiving roles that foster emotional intelligence and responsibility, while younger siblings may have more opportunity for self-expression.

Differential Acculturation

Differential acculturation is the process by which siblings adapt to the dominant culture at different rates. Even within the same family, children have different experiences with cultural exposure depending on their age and peer associations.

One sibling may readily assimilate into mainstream culture by adopting its language and norms, while another maintains stronger ties to the heritage culture. This divergence affects relationships, educational involvement, and social experiences. Those who socialize primarily within mainstream culture may develop different perspectives than those who remain more connected to their heritage culture.

Differential acculturation can have complex effects on sibling relationships. One sibling may serve as a cultural mediator, while another may feel misunderstood or left behind. These dynamics can foster admiration and mutual learning or create tension and emotional distance.

Over time, these differing cultural experiences influence identity, notions of belonging, and long-term life decisions. Siblings can grow up in the same household yet develop vastly different attitudes towards culture and self-expression.

• Family Dynamics
• Take our Family Estrangement Test for the Adult Child
• Find a Family Therapy Therapist

Family Dynamics and Parental Expectations

Each family adapts differently to each child, even when parents try to treat all of their children equally. Parental expectations may change according to the child’s temperament, academic abilities, gender, and perceived strengths. In immigrant families, such differences are often influenced by collectivist and achievement-oriented cultural values.

Some children may be expected to take on more responsibility through household tasks, taking care of siblings, or functioning as a bridge between parents and external systems. Others may be protected from these responsibilities, allowing them more emotional freedom.

These distinct roles help shape self-concept and confidence. Children who often help or act as mediators may develop strong communication skills and leadership qualities, while others may develop traits like creativity or independence. Usually, these roles are not explicitly assigned, yet they leave a deep impact.

Family Dynamics Essential Reads

Identity Formation and Personal Growth

Sibling differences are not solely the product of family structure or culture; individual personality and coping strategies play an important role. Each child responds differently to expectations and pressures. Some embrace the roles expected of them and carry the mantle of tradition, while others seek independence or cultural distance.

Immigrant children often develop distinct cultural identities. Some create "bridge identities," navigating heritage and dominant cultures comfortably, while others align more strongly with one cultural framework, which guides their sense of belonging and emotional security.

Variations in resilience, emotional expressiveness, and interests are natural results of such interactions. These differences influence educational choices, relationships, and long-term goals that contribute to the distinct life path of each sibling.

Supporting Healthy Sibling Relationships and Individual Growth

The role of parents or caregivers should in no way be undermined in supporting both individuation and sibling bonding. It is important to recognize the strengths of each child rather than fostering competition through comparisons.

Open discussions regarding family cultural expectations, roles within the family, and personal interests can help develop trust. Creating opportunities for collaborative activities, shared interests, or teamwork enables siblings to maintain strong relationships despite living different lives. A nurturing environment allows siblings to recognize the value of their differences.

Conclusion

It is common for siblings, especially those from immigrant families, to develop different identities and life trajectories despite sharing the same parents and home environment, due to factors such as birth order, differential acculturation, and individual temperament. Families can support both individual development and sibling relationships by acknowledging and respecting the different experiences each sibling undergoes.