View PDF

Abstract:Our systematisation of knowledge on Social Engineering Attacks (SEAs), identifies the human, organisational, and adversarial dimensions of cyber threats. It addresses the growing risks posed by SEAs, highly relevant in the context physical cyber places, such as travellers at airports and residents in smart cities, and synthesizes findings from peer reviewed studies, industry and government reports to inform effective countermeasures that can be embedded into future smart city strategies. SEAs increasingly sidestep technical controls by weaponising leaked personal data and behavioural cues, an urgency underscored by the Optus, Medibank and now Qantas (2025) mega breaches that placed millions of personal records in criminals’ hands. Our review surfaces three critical dimensions: (i) human factors of knowledge, abilities and behaviours (KAB) (ii) organisational culture and informal norms that shape those behaviours and (iii) attacker motivations, techniques and return on investment calculations. Our contributions are threefold: (1) TriLayer Systematisation: to the best of our knowledge, we are the first to unify KAB metrics, cultural drivers and attacker economics into a single analytical lens, enabling practitioners to see how vulnerabilities, norms and threat incentives coevolve. (2) Risk Weighted HAISQ Meta analysis: By normalising and ranking HAISQ scores across recent field studies, we reveal persistent high risk clusters (Internet and Social Media use) and propose impact weightings that make the instrument predictive rather than descriptive. (3) Adaptive ‘Segment and Simulate’ Training Blueprint: Building on clustering evidence, we outline a differentiated programme that matches low, medium, high risk user cohorts to experiential learning packages including phishing simulations, gamified challenges and realtime feedback thereby aligning effort with measured exposure.

Submission history

From: Scott Thomson [view email] [v1] Fri, 19 Dec 2025 08:57:27 UTC (589 KB)