Public Review Kicks Off for Boys & Girls Club Site in Downtown Brooklyn
Two years after buying the property, Alloy Development wants to turn it into a high-rise development with housing, retail, and a new school.
Alloy Development is planning to develop a new school, retail space, and housing at 240 Nassau Street. Rendering via Alloy Development
by Kirstyn Brendlen, Brooklyn Paper
Two years after it bought the former Boys & Girls Club building in Fort Greene, Alloy Development has unveiled its plans to turn the site — and half the block it sits on — into a high-rise mixed-use development with hundreds of apartments and comm…
Public Review Kicks Off for Boys & Girls Club Site in Downtown Brooklyn
Two years after buying the property, Alloy Development wants to turn it into a high-rise development with housing, retail, and a new school.
Alloy Development is planning to develop a new school, retail space, and housing at 240 Nassau Street. Rendering via Alloy Development
by Kirstyn Brendlen, Brooklyn Paper
Two years after it bought the former Boys & Girls Club building in Fort Greene, Alloy Development has unveiled its plans to turn the site — and half the block it sits on — into a high-rise mixed-use development with hundreds of apartments and community space spread across three separate buildings.
Working with the city’s Educational Construction Fund and GFB Development, Alloy is seeking to rezone 240 Nassau Street and the neighboring 46 Navy Street, currently home to P.S. 287, to make way for the project. The first step of the Uniform Land Use Review Procedure, an environmental review, kicked off on Monday, with public review expected to start in early 2026.
The project would include 1,500 new apartments with 305 affordable units, 95 of which would be set aside for seniors. There would also be a new 27,000-square-foot community center, a 15,000-square-foot cultural center, and a new school to replace P.S. 287.
The proposed new buildings. Rendering via Alloy Development 
The footprint of the new project, which includes three separate buildings with housing, retail stores, a new school, and community spaces. Map via Alloy Development
Renderings show one high-rise building in place of the current Boys & Girls Club at 240 Nassau Street with the community and cultural centers on the ground floor and apartments above. Two buildings on Navy Street would take up the footprint of the existing school. One of those buildings, at the corner of Navy and Nassau streets, would house the school and retail. The other, a high-rise next door, would include the senior housing as well as other units and stores.
The high-rises, located at 240 Nassau Street and at the corner of Navy and Concord streets, would stand at about 700 feet and 850 feet tall, respectively.
“240 Nassau is a transformative, community-driven development that, with local stakeholder support, can deliver much-needed affordable and senior housing, a new public school, and open space, along with community and cultural facilities,” said Alloy CEO Jared Della Valle in a statement. “We’re proud to bring a meaningful investment to a community that’s long been underserved and to continue to strengthen Downtown Brooklyn for decades to come.”
The proposed cultural center, which would serve as an extension of the Cultural Museum of African Art. Rendering via Alloy Development 
The proposed new buildings along Nassau and Navy streets. Rendering via Alloy Development
Alloy purchased 240 Nassau Street from the Boys & Girls Club in 2023, after the organization was forced to sell as part of a court settlement. Since then, the developer has allowed the nonprofit to use the building for its after-school programming, and has provided free space to six other nonprofits.
Concurrently, the developer said, it has held a “comprehensive community engagement” process regarding the future of the site, and has hosted meetings with community organizations, NYCHA tenant groups, and other locals to help determine what the neighborhood needs.
The firm is partnering with GFB Development, a real estate firm founded by former Knicks player Taj Gibson and two of his childhood friends, Tameek Floyd and Malik Brown, in an effort to provide affordable housing and recreational spaces to underserved communities. The trio grew up in nearby Ingersoll Houses, and Floyd and Brown both attended P.S. 287 and were members of the Boys & Girls Club.
The proposed design of the new school building on Navy Street. Rendering via Alloy Development
“I’m proud to help bring 240 Nassau and a new school to the neighborhood that raised me,” Gibson said in a statement. “The goal is to create an environment where families can thrive and our children are given the tools to be the best they can be. Our future is bright.”
The company said the new community center will replace the Boys & Girls Club, with an operator to be chosen in line with community feedback.
Plans for the cultural center are more definite: It is expected to serve as an expansion of the Cultural Museum of African Art’s Eric Edwards Collection, with gallery, educational, and research facilities.
The Boys & Girls Club building at 240 Nassau Street in 2012. Photo by Christopher Bride for PropertyShark 
P.S. 287 at 46 Navy Steret in 2012. Photo by Christopher Bride for PropertyShark
The existing Boys & Girls Club and school would be demolished as part of the project. Alloy said the Department of Education would work to find interim spaces for students to relocate during construction, and that Alloy would “work with the community to ensure continuation of existing after-school programming.”
The basketball courts behind the Boys & Girls Club and Galconda Park, which sits on the other end of the block, on Gold Street, would remain as is, renderings show. The project would include 21,000 square feet of new public open space between the two buildings on Navy Street.
Developers expect to finish the ULURP process next year and, if the project is approved, start construction in 2027.
Bisected by highways since the mid-20th century thanks to Robert Moses and recently the site of scattered multi-family development, the historic low-rise residential neighborhood includes early to mid 19th century houses. One of the most well known is 167 Concord Street, a petite Federal style house that may date from the early 19th century or earlier.
Editor’s note: A version of this story originally ran in Brooklyn Paper. Click here to see the original story.
Related Stories
- Demo Starts at Bay Ridge’s Former Century 21 Site for New Retail Complex
- Construction Begins on Final Mixed-Use Tower at Williamsburg’s Domino Site
- Steel Skeleton for New Brooklyn Jail Reaches Eighth Floor in Boreum Hill
Email tips@brownstoner.com with further comments, questions or tips. Follow Brownstoner on X and Instagram, and like us on Facebook.