An Axiomatic Theory of Tie-Breaking: Impossibility, Characterization, and Decomposition (opens in new tab)

We develop an abstract axiomatic theory of tie-breaking. A tie-breaking input consists of a finite set N of players, a weak order on N representing the standings to be refined, and an auxiliary information item drawn from a set on which the symmetric group Sym(N) acts. Within this minimal framework we prove three theorems. First, no tie-breaking rule producing a strict linear order can be anonymous, provided the input space contains even one int...