From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article is about proposals to federalise the European Union. For hypothetical and historical proposals, see Federal Europe. For the political doctrine of European cultural integration, see European values. For the process of integration in Europe in general, see European integration.

There is ongoing discussion about the extent to which the European Union (EU) has already turned from a confederation (a union of sovereign states) into a federation (a single federal state with a central government, consisting of a number of partially self-governing federated states) over the course of decades, and more importantly, to what degree it should continue to evolve in a federalist direction. As of June 2024, the EU has no formal plans to become a federation.

Since the 1950s, European integration has seen the development of a supranational system of governance, as its institutions move further from the concept of simple intergovernmentalism and more towards a federalised system.[citation needed] However, with the Maastricht Treaty of 1992, new intergovernmental elements have been introduced alongside the more federal systems, making it more difficult to define the EU. The European Union, which operates through a hybrid system – thus often described as sui generis – of intergovernmentalism and supranationalism, is not officially a federation or even a confederation, although many contemporary scholars of federalism view it as a federal system.[1]

The College of Europe in Belgium was founded after the 1948 Hague Congress, a pivotal moment in European federal history that also led to the creation of the European Movement.

A Pan-European movement gained some momentum from the 1920s with the creation of the Paneuropean Union, based on Richard von Coudenhove-Kalergi’s 1923 manifesto Paneuropa, which presented the idea of a unified European State. This movement, led by Coudenhove-Kalergi and subsequently by Otto von Habsburg, is the oldest European unification movement.[2][3][4] His ideas influenced Aristide Briand, who gave a speech in favour of a European Union in the League of Nations on 8 September 1929, and in 1930, who wrote his “Memorandum on the Organization of a Regime of European Federal Union” for the Government of France.[5]

At the end of World War II, the political climate favoured unity in Western Europe, seen by many as an escape from the extreme forms of nationalism which had devastated the continent.[6]

One of the first practical and successful proposals for European cooperation came in 1951 with the European Coal and Steel Community. Since then, the European Community has gradually evolved to Union in which a whole range of policy areas where its member states hope to benefit from working together.

The process of intergovernmentally pooling powers, harmonising national policies and creating and enforcing supranational institutions, is called European integration. Other than the vague aim of “ever closer union” in the 1983 Solemn Declaration on European Union, the Union (meaning its member governments) has no current policy to create a federal state.

Debate on European unity is often vague as to the boundaries of ‘Europe’. The word ‘Europe’ is widely used as a synonym for the European Union, although most of the European continent’s geographical area is not in the EU, and some of the EU is outside of Europe (e.g. French Guiana). Most of Europe’s people do, however, live in the EU.

Multi-speed integration

[edit]

The multi-speed Europe thesis envisions an alternative type of European integration, where the EU countries that want a more integrated EU can accelerate their own integration, whereas other countries may go at a slower pace or cease further integration altogether. Specific current examples include the Eurozone and the Schengen Area, which not all members have joined.

An Euler diagram showing the relationships between various multinational European organisations and agreements

• v
• t
• e

The European Union (EU) is not legally (de jure) a federation, although various academics have argued that it contains some federal characteristics. About how various scholars approach the issue, R. Daniel Kelemen of Rutgers University said: “Unencumbered by the prejudice that the EU is sui generis and incomparable, federalism scholars now regularly treat the EU as a case in their comparative studies (Friedman-Goldstein, 2001; Filippov, Ordeshook, Shevtsova, 2004; Roden, 2005; Bednar, 2006). For the purposes of the present analysis, the EU has the necessary minimal attributes of a federal system and crucially the EU is riven with many of the same tensions that afflict federal systems.”[1]

According to Joseph H. H. Weiler, “Europe has charted its own brand of constitutional federalism”.[7] Jean-Michel Josselin and Alain Marciano see the European Court of Justice as being a primary force behind building a federal legal order in the Union[8] with Josselin stating that “A complete shift from a confederation to a federation would have required to straightforwardly replace the principality of the member states vis-à-vis the Union by that of the European citizens. … As a consequence, both confederate and federate features coexist in the judicial landscape.”[9]

Thomas Risse and Tanja A. Börzel wrote: “The EU only lacks two significant features of a federation. First, the Member States remain the ‘masters’ of the treaties, i.e., they have the exclusive power to amend or change the constitutive treaties of the EU. Second, the EU lacks a real ‘tax and spend’ capacity, in other words, there is no fiscal federalism.”[10]

Other academics have argued that the EU is unlikely to evolve into a unified federal state. Kelemen has taken this view himself in a paper co-written with Andy Tarrant, arguing that limits placed on the bureaucratic capacity of the European institutions – such as the relatively small size of the European Commission – form a barrier to the creation of a federal European state. In their words: “widespread political opposition to the creation of anything approximating a large, unified executive bureaucracy in Brussels has long-since ended hopes, for the few who harboured them, of creating a European superstate.”[11] Some common points in this context are that the European budget is very small and does not finance a lot of the economic activity of the European Union; that each member state of the European Union has its own foreign relations and its own military; that it is often the case that European Union member states decide to opt out of agreements which they oppose; and that member states still retain sovereignty over a large number of areas which might be expected to be transferred to a federal authority under a federal system. One important fact is that treaties must be agreed by all member states even if a particular treaty has support among the vast majority of the population of the European Union. Member states may also want legally binding guarantees that a particular treaty will not affect a nation’s position on certain issues.

Use of the word ‘federal’ is itself the cause of some disagreement. Valéry Giscard d’Estaing found opposition from the United Kingdom towards including the word “federal” in the proposed European Constitution, and hence replaced the word with “Community”.[12][13][14]

In November 2021, the incoming German government, the Scholz cabinet, called for European federalism in the coalition agreement and wanted to help achieve this.[15][16]

• Anti-Europeanism – Political term for opposition to Europe
• Arab Union – Ideology espousing the unification of the Arab world
• Consociationalism – Political power sharing among cultural groups
• Democracy in Europe Movement 2025 – Left-wing European political alliance
• European Federalist Party – French political party and former European political alliance
• European Movement International – Lobbying association for European integration
• Euroscepticism – Body of criticism of the European Union
• Nation state – Political term for a state that is based around a nation
• Politics of Europe
• Pro-Europeanism – Favouring European integration
• Pulse of Europe – Citizen’s initiative for pan-Europeanism
• Sovereignty – Supreme authority within a territory
• Spinelli Group – Campaign for a federal Europe
• Stand Up for Europe – Movement for democracy & federalism
• Subsidiarity (European Union) – Principle of governance of the European Union
• Union of European Federalists – Non-governmental organisation, campaigning for a Federal Europe
• United States of Africa – Political concept similar to the hypothesised United States of Europe
• United States of Europe – Speculative future European federation
• United States of Europe (electoral list)
• Volt Europa – Federalist European political alliance

1. ^ a b Kelemen, R. Daniel. (2007). “Built to Last? The Durability of EU Federalism?” (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 20 January 2013. In Making History: State of the European Union, Vol. 8, edited by Sophie Meunier and Kate McNamara, Oxford University Press, p. 52.
2. ^ Otto von Habsburg: Die Paneuropäische Idee. Eine Vision wird Wirklichkeit. Amalthea Verlag, Wien-München 1999, ISBN 3-85002-424-5
3. ^ Vanessa Conze: Das Europa der Deutschen; Ideen von Europa in Deutschland zwischen Reichstradition und Westorientierung (1920–1970); Oldenbourg Wissenschaftsverlag; 2005; ISBN 978-3-486-57757-0.
4. ^ Ben Rosamond, Theories of European Integration, Palgrave Macmillan, 2000, pp. 21–22.
5. ^ D. Weigall and P. Stirk, editors, The Origins and Development of the European Community, Leicester: Leicester University Press, 1992, pp. 11–15.
6. ^ “The political consequences”. European NAvigator. Archived from the original on 9 August 2011. Retrieved 5 September 2007.
7. ^ J.H.H. Weiler (2003). “Chapter 2, Federalism without Constitutionalism: Europe’s Sonderweg”. The federal vision: legitimacy and levels of governance in the United States and the European Union. Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-924500-2. Europe has charted its own brand of constitutional federalism. It works. Why fix it?
8. ^ Josselin, Jean-Michel; Marciano, Alain (2007). “How the court made a federation of the EU”. The Review of International Organizations. 2: 59–75. doi:10.1007/s11558-006-9001-y.
9. ^ Josselin, Jean Michel; Marciano, Alain (2006). “The political economy of European federalism” (PDF). Series: Public Economics and Social Choice. Centre for Research in Economics and Management, University of Rennes 1, University of Caen. p. 12. WP 2006–07; UMR CNRS 6211. Archived from the original (PDF) on 19 August 2008.
10. ^ Thomas Risse and Tanja A. Börzel, The European Union as an Emerging Federal System Archived 10 October 2008 at the Wayback Machine, Jean Monnet Center at NYU School of Law
11. ^ Kelemen, R. Daniel; Tarrant, Andy (2007). “Building the Eurocracy” (PDF).
12. ^ Evans-Pritchard, Ambrose (8 July 2003). “Giscard’s ‘federal’ ruse to protect Blair”. The Daily Telegraph. London. Archived from the original on 14 January 2013. Retrieved 15 October 2008.
13. ^ Thomas, Sean (22 June 2003). “Gobbledegook”. The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 15 October 2008.[dead link]
14. ^ d’Estaing, V. G. (7 July 2003). “Unknown title”. The Wall Street Journal Europe. I knew the word ‘federal’ was ill-perceived by the British and a few others. I thought that it wasn’t worth creating a negative commotion, which could prevent them supporting something that otherwise they would have supported. … So I rewrote my text, replacing intentionally the word ‘federal’ with the word ‘communautaire’, which means exactly the same thing.
15. ^ “German government will push for a European federation”. euractiv.com. 25 November 2021. Retrieved 26 November 2021.
16. ^ “What’s in the German coalition deal for Europe (and the UK)”. Politico Europe. 24 November 2021. Retrieved 26 November 2021.

• European Integration: Westphalian Cooperation or Federalization?
• Political speeches by Victor Hugo: Victor Hugo, My Revenge is Fraternity!, where he used the term United States of Europe.
• Jürgen Habermas. Towards a United States of Europe, signandsight.com
• Analysis: What would a federal Europe look like? Archived 13 August 2007 at the Wayback Machine
• Archival sources deposited by various Federal European Movements and its leaders are consultable at the Historical Archives of the European Union in Florence
• The European Federalist Papers Archived 28 March 2022 at the Wayback Machine