A while back I went down a deep rabbit hole looking into surge protectors, and what all the different numbers mean, and how that affects things in case of a voltage spike. Then I didn’t really do anything with the information, other than bore a few friends, and look around in despair at all the shockingly bad products out there. Time to fix that!
I’m coming at this from the angle of a computer user in a country with very good electrical regulations. If you’re protecting something else, or live somewhere that doesn’t believe in grounding things, your mileage may vary.
Building a better mental model
I think when most of us think of surge protectors, we think of an extension lead with some magical property that stops surges and protects everything plugged into them. It’s a bit like the shield on the USS Enterprise. If we put the shields up in time, they’ll stop everything thrown at them, until at some point they’re overloaded and stop working. Only then will we have problems. There’s even a little LED that goes out when she cannae take it any more, cap’n.
Of course, if that was actually the case, I wouldn’t be writing a blog post. Surge protectors are more like the crumple zone on a car. If you hit something, the crumple zone will absorb some of the impact, but you can quite easily still get injured. If the impact is big enough then the crumple zone will bleed some energy, but you’re still going to have a very bad time. My point here is that it’s not a perfect shield, can be overcome with a single excessive impact, and doesn’t magically recharge back to full strength.
The numbers, Mason! What do they mean?
To understand what protection these things really offer, we need to look at a couple of numbers. Unfortunately, they’re not the numbers that are displayed in the marketing. Sometimes they’re not even on the spec sheet. Most of the time they’re on the actual device, and if they’re not then it’s safe to just assume things are bad.
The most important number is the let-through voltage, Up. It may also be called the clamping voltage, the voltage protection rating, or the VPR. This is the voltage that will be let through, before the surge protector does anything1. We use 230V mains, with a +10%/-6% tolerance. So we shouldn’t be seeing anything above 253V. If you were designing a surge protector, you’d want it to engage a little above this, right? Maybe call it 300V so it doesn’t cut in prematurely? If you have a surge protector nearby, I invite you to try and find its Up value. If you don’t have one, you can follow along with mine:
A not-very-good surge protector. Please take a moment to consider how difficult it was to make this text readable.